Negotiating Learner Differences MOOC’s Updates
Inclusive Lang. in biology
This is my first year teaching in an introductory biology course in my home country, Ecuador. Most of the students are in their first year. A challenge that I have faced so far is the use of inclusive language when I teach sex determination in humans. The way this is explained in textbooks and the way I learned this is that females have XX chromosomes and males have XY chromosomes. However, this approach does not touch on the differences between gender and sex. I don’t know if any of my students are transgender, but I still think it would be important for cisgender people to be more aware of this. In this sense, I think the way I taught this material originally was exclusionary and may have helped reinforce transphobic ideas (Dennis 2017, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eWVRzGMVXbM). I also don’t feel fluent enough in this subject and am a bit intimidated to discuss it in a classromm. I think a good place to start is looking for trans people’s thoughts on this. For example, one teacher suggested mentioning a lot of different ways in which sex is determined in nature (Maday-Travis n.d., https://www.glsen.org/blog/6-ways-i-make-my-science-class-lgbtq-inclusive-trans-teacher). I think the major challenge is that Spanish is a gendered language, so that every noun has a gender. I am not sure if this means that the fact that a chair is a “she” and a couch is a “he” means that these objects carry “female/male” characteristics. But it does make it harder to speak in an inclusive way about XY and XX individuals. Alternatively, it might be that this subject is a good way of starting a conversation. I think this would be useful for all of us who are not fluent in sex-gender theories. However, it might also turn into a space where people say things that might be hurtful. I would greatly appreciate any input on this!
@Ana Eguiguren, this is so interesting and something I hadn't considered in the context of teaching biology. It's tough to be restricted by textbook methods when you're mindful of being inclusive of transgender and non-binary people, but I think your consideration and mindfulness here is the first step towards being inclusive and opening conversation. I agree that this subject is a great way to start a conversation... my best advice to prevent people from sharing hurtful comments would be to set clear guidelines for what is acceptable and not acceptable in discussion, and perhaps seek advice from trans and non-binary people in how to best approach this discussion.