An AI-Human Partnership: A Phenomenological Exploration of Graduate Students’ Lived Experiences and Ethical Tensions in AI-Enhanced Learning

Abstract

This study explored graduate students’ lived experiences and ethical tensions when using generative artificial intelligence (AI) in an accelerated online Master of Education course. Thirty-eight participants engaged with Microsoft Copilot AI for three guided assignments focused on assessment design, each accompanied by reflective journals. The conceptual framework was transcendental phenomenology, which guided the research through bracketing, horizontalization, clustering, textual descriptions, and synthesis to capture the essence of students’ experiences. The methods were qualitative, utilizing written reflective journals from each of the three assignment submissions using AI, for a total of 114. Findings reveal that students perceived AI as a valuable instructional guide. However, participants also described internal conflicts regarding academic integrity, expressing both appreciation for AI’s feedback and concerns about ethical boundaries. The study highlights a spectrum of attitudes, from increased confidence in AI to skepticism and discomfort with its limitations. These insights provide a nuanced understanding of how graduate students navigate the benefits and challenges of AI-enhanced learning, offering implications for ethical practice and instructional design in higher education.

Presenters

Leticia De Leon
Professor, Teaching and Learning Department, University of Texas Rio Grande Valley, Texas, United States

Details

Presentation Type

Paper Presentation in a Themed Session

Theme

2026 Special Focus—Human-Centered AI Transformations

KEYWORDS

Artificial Intelligence, Ethical Tensions, Lived Experiences